Image: BioWare

Are you a gamer who prefers Dragon Age: Inquisition over The Witcher 3? Strangely enough, the guy responsible for overseeing the development of BioWare’s critically acclaimed 2014 action RPG would be unlikely to agree with you. Aaryn Flynn, who served as Studio General Manager for BioWare at the time, told GLHF in a new interview about how he thought The Witcher 3 was a better game than what his own company came up with for the third installment of Dragon Age. Flynn suggests that Inquisition could have been even better if it weren’t for Frostbite, an engine that seemingly made developing the game more difficult than it had to be.

The Witcher 3 ‘was better’ than Dragon Age: Inquisition, admits BioWare’s Aaryn Flynn (FTW)

“To bend it to make RPG elements was certainly a challenge,” Flynn says. “It resulted in compromises and things that we certainly didn’t want to do if it weren’t for the technology limitations. But the team found incredibly clever and reasonable ways around that whenever they could. I haven’t touched it in five years, so I can’t tell you where it’s at now, but I still see the bugs being recorded by players and other games and go, ‘Ah, that’s too bad.’

“Mark Darrah, the former executive producer, had a famous line: ‘Frostbite has no notion of player or health,’ or something like that. There are just things that make you like, ‘Oh, my God, what? Okay, we’ve got to do that.’ But I’d say the biggest compromise came from the fact that we had to ship Inquisition on the Xbox 360 and PS3 at the same time as we did on the PS4 and Xbox One. That crushed so much ambition because we didn’t have the team size or the time to differentiate those things, truly. So you had to kind of develop the lowest common denominator. And as that came in, that certainly beat out some expectations and ambitions we had for certain fun features in gameplay. In contrast, CD Projekt didn’t do that with The Witcher 3, a few months later, and I think their game was better for it.”

Looking back over his time at BioWare, Flynn’s biggest regret also comes back to Dragon Age: Inquisition and Frostbite. While he’s proud of the team and what they achieved under difficult circumstances, he wishes he’d been better at communicating the issues to the higher-ups.

“Being a programmer, I underestimated the difficulty that Frostbite was presenting to our dev teams, and I wish I wish I’ve done a better job of communicating that to the top brass at EA,” he explains. “I wish I’d been understanding of the friction the engine created for us building a very different kind of game. I see it now in the news reports and in the press, so I kind of get it, but I think I could have done a better job. I could have used the fact that I had a history of engineering to better communicate things rather than believing and trusting the way engineers are smart, we’ll figure it out as we sometimes have in the past.”

Go to thread

Don’t Miss Out on More FPS Review Content!

Our weekly newsletter includes a recap of our reviews and a run down of the most popular tech news that we published.

8 comments

  1. Kind of makes me wonder what going to the UE for the next witcher game will have for consequences.

    You have to hope the engine is easier adaptable to their vision for the game then adapting their own one, guess we will find out in a decade orso.
  2. Kind of makes me wonder what going to the UE for the next witcher game will have for consequences.

    You have to hope the engine is easier adaptable to their vision for the game then adapting their own one, guess we will find out in a decade orso.

    Just a guess as to how it will go ...

    tracks.jpg
  3. Not sure if a more accessible engine would've helped Dragon Age Inquisition that much. A lot of the gameplay in the game was filler-style content, I remember some of the maps felt like a boring slog (especially the tedious DLC content). Witcher 3 on the other hand, every quest in that game felt involved and its DLC only improved the game (B&W being easily as strong as the main campaign).
  4. That's not a high bar. To this day I Do not understand why Inquisition was so well recieved. It is an MMO disguised as a single player game, tedious and boring, where the main quest is overshadowed by all the repetitive collection and fetch quests. And it's showing all signs of wokism, before wokism was trending on twitter.
  5. He didn't necessarily say Witcher 3 was better than DA:I. He said Witcher 3 benefited ("was better") from not shipping on XBox 360 and PS3 and having to deal with the limitations of those platforms.

    I've never played DA:I, so I can't personally say one is better than the other. Witcher 3 is pretty **** good, though.
  6. I didn't know DA:I released on XB360 or PS3 either -- but apparently it did, even though it was released more than a year following the PS4/XBone generation.

    As a game, I would say DA:O was my favorite, but DA:I wasn't bad. I did like it better than W3, but that's mostly just that I never could get into Witcher for some reason - I would acknowledge that W3 is regarded as one of the best games (or at least shortlisted as such) of all time by many.
  7. I mean, yeah, filler, but DA: Inquisition was still a decent game. And while comparisons with TW3 are valid in the ballpark sense, they're still rather different games.

    As for UE5, I'm betting that the main draw is the portability. Devs can focus on content - their strength, otherwise rather uncommon in the industry - while using a first-class engine to keep the visuals up along with compatibility.

    I'm betting the CP2077 fiasco really put a damper on their internal business case for using their home-grown engine.
  8. I mean, yeah, filler, but DA: Inquisition was still a decent game. And while comparisons with TW3 are valid in the ballpark sense, they're still rather different games.

    The witcher has it's fair share of filler but also has more original content, but as you said they are different games, and even if both have their flaws, they are both worth playing imho.

Leave a comment

Please log in to your forum account to comment