Microsoft Says That Limited Resources Prevent It from Using AMD in Surface Devices Even as It Partners with Other Vendors for Its Mobile PCs

The FPS Review may receive a commission if you purchase something after clicking a link in this article.

Image: Microsoft

Microsoft says that it maintains a good working relationship with AMD despite that it continues to work with many others, but not Team Red, for its Surface brand mobile PCs. Given that both Intel and Qualcomm currently provide processors for Surface devices, and there’s something in the works with NVIDIA, it is peculiar that Surface customers are not presented with another option. Essentially, AMD is the only major processor manufacturer, other than competitor Apple, to be left out of the room when it comes to having an offering in the lineup, but this wasn’t always so.

Once upon a time, not too long ago, AMD was included, albeit for a brief time, with the Surface Laptop 3 in 2019 and then also the Laptop 4, but then not seen again in Surface devices after. Interestingly enough, AMD does maintain a working relationship with Microsoft by producing processors for Xbox consoles, which includes future next-gen products. AMD and Microsoft recently renewed their agreements to work together for Xbox devices, although there’s still no word on when the next batch will arrive. Meanwhile, Windows Central Insider has reached out to Microsoft regarding its decision not to use AMD with its Surface lineups and was told that, basically, it comes down to limited resources and that things are still good between the two companies.

“We love working with AMD. We have a limited portfolio, and so we have to make our choices pretty wisely in terms of what we’re doing and where we’re doing,” Ostrum told me, before proclaiming “I love working with AMD.”

– Brett Ostrum, Surface Corporate Vice President

While this response may seem clear, it does leave one to wonder if there could be more at play than is being said. Perhaps AMD is unable to procure enough foundry time to produce enough processors for Microsoft. Maybe the two cannot reach agreeable terms to offer a competitive product at a price Microsoft wants to adhere to. It could also be as simple as is stated, and Microsoft is limited by what it can currently offer, but then what if it doesn’t want to flood the market with too many choices or oversaturated branding? Well, no matter, there you have it on why we no longer see an AMD logo on Surface devices.

Join the discussion in The FPS Review Forums...

Discussion (18 replies)

Join Discussion →
Marees
Marees 👍 1

makes no sense why the Surface guys hate AMD

stuff was so bad that when xbox initially decided on doing a first party handheld they gave the job to the surface division, who — naturally — chose an arm processor. luckily the whole thing was scrapped / shelved in favor of third party OEM stuff such as Rog Ally X

U

Idk, is AMD finally great at laptops? For so many years, specs read great but implementation: always below competition

Brian_B
Brian_B 👍 3

"Limited Resources"

As in AMD limited the amount of monetary resources they were willing to provide to Microsoft to do such a thing?

U
Uvilla 👍 2

Somehow, billions in profit, means limited resources, uh- huh uh- huh yep yep.

Peter_Brosdahl
Peter_Brosdahl 👍 1

"Uvilla, post: 107385, member: 397" wrote:

Idk, is AMD finally great at laptops? For so many years, specs read great but implementation: always below competition


and hard as f to get in reality. I still remember several years ago pre-ordering an ASUS with an RTX 4090 mobile laptop six months in advance which had the equivalent of a mobile 9950 CPU and a month after it was supposed to launch ASUS cancelled it. As quick as I was to want to blame them it turns out the AMD version never launched at all.

Then last year when the 5090 mobile finally made its way to the U.S. the AMD X3D mobile processor was nowhere to be found even though it'd been listed on store pages in Asia for six months prior. I'm happy with the Intel chip mine came with but I would've preferred AMDs offering.

Marees

Microsoft surface division plans to continue to torture AMD !!

[embedded media]

U
Uvilla 👍 2

So everybody and their dog has an arm cpu... For the first time, i think truly the direction for x86 is death. Yes it will take some time, but i think x86 been marked for deprecation, i mean fully marked.
The adoption of arm at all levels is simply snowballing massively.
From, no too hard to do 20yrs ago, to whatver we have coverted our software already to arm, like quickly.

Grimlakin
Grimlakin 👍 2

AI wants arm because with so many cores it's very easy to hide compute use from stupid humans.

;)

i
igor_kavinski 👍 1

"Uvilla, post: 107898, member: 397" wrote:

So everybody and their dog has an arm cpu... For the first time, i think truly the direction for x86 is death. Yes it will take some time, but i think x86 been marked for deprecation, i mean fully marked.


x86 players will not give up their baby that easily and they will compete aggressively with ARM. Because if they are left with no choice but to license ARM, they end up paying royalties to ARM (Softbank) which they never want to do. It would be the ultimate defeat if that comes to pass.

I think even Apple might be working behind the scenes on their own royalty-free RISC-V CPU so they can own everything and not pay a penny in licensing fees.

Brian_B

"igor_kavinski, post: 107911, member: 10805" wrote:

x86 players will not give up their baby that easily and they will compete aggressively with ARM. Because if they are left with no choice but to license ARM, they end up paying royalties to ARM (Softbank) which they never want to do. It would be the ultimate defeat if that comes to pass.



I think even Apple might be working behind the scenes on their own royalty-free RISC-V CPU so they can own everything and not pay a penny in licensing fees.


You know, the royalties we’ve been paying for
x86 all these years hasn’t exactly been cheap either.

Maybe it isn’t a dollar figure, per say, but a severe limiting of offerings and high die prices. Not like Caruso and Cyrix are still out there helping with competition…

i
igor_kavinski 👍 1

"Brian_B, post: 107912, member: 96" wrote:

x86 all these years hasn’t exactly been cheap either.


Single core 1 GHz CPUs used to be priced at $1000 (Extreme Edition and Athlon FX). We are comparatively very lucky these days. Someone on overclock.net is selling a decent binned Core 270K for just $200.

Peter_Brosdahl
Peter_Brosdahl 👍 2

"igor_kavinski, post: 107914, member: 10805" wrote:

We are comparatively very lucky these days.


almost entirely agree except for the lack of lanes available at the consumer level. Not that I truly need them but I do miss having the option.

i
igor_kavinski 👍 1

"Peter_Brosdahl, post: 107938, member: 87" wrote:

almost entirely agree except for the lack of lanes available at the consumer level. Not that I truly need them but I do miss having the option.


If they gave that away, their HEDT sales would crash coz most of the users are buying those more for the lanes than the quad channel RAM or extra cores. I do wish they would introduce an HEDT Jr. platform with triple channel RAM, dual sockets that accept only consumer CPUs and 50% more lanes than the desktop platform. It would sell well. And if they can set it up so that you are running different OSes on each CPU and can switch between them on the fly (a UEFI based hypervisor) then that would be even more enticing. So many times I've looked at some Linux software wistfully but unable to try it because I don't want to run a VM and they still don't have vertical M2 slots on mobos so you can just pop in an NVMe stick and start working right away.

i
igor_kavinski 👍 1

"Brian_B, post: 107912, member: 96" wrote:

Not like Caruso and Cyrix are still out there helping with competition…


That was bugging me coz never heard about that and then google told me, maybe you mean Transmeta Crusoe! It was a really cool concept.

This is the modern successor: https://www.linkedin.com/posts/patmoorhead_nuvacore-is-flipping-the-order-of-operations-activity-7510767776479825923-Orw1

When launched, they are hinting that it will be able to run x86, ARM or RISC-V code coz it's ISA agnostic.

Grimlakin
Grimlakin 👍 1

"igor_kavinski, post: 107941, member: 10805" wrote:

That was bugging me coz never heard about that and then google told me, maybe you mean Transmeta Crusoe! It was a really cool concept.



This is the modern successor: https://www.linkedin.com/posts/patmoorhead_nuvacore-is-flipping-the-order-of-operations-activity-7510767776479825923-Orw1



When launched, they are hinting that it will be able to run x86, ARM or RISC-V code coz it's ISA agnostic.

sounds like the material pipe dreams, faster gates than carbon nanotube, runs at 1/20th the power, and generates 1/1000th the heat... Capable of densities 5000x the current generation blah blah blah...

While we need those moonshot goals... they tend to list them as turn the page and we are there!

Peter Brosdahl
As a child of the 70’s I was part of the many who became enthralled by the video arcade invasion of the 1980’s. Saving money from various odd jobs I purchased my first computer from a friend of my dad, a used Atari 400, around 1982. Eventually it would end up being a lifelong passion of upgrading and modifying equipment that, of course, led into a career in IT support.

Recent News