The NH-D15 G2, a next-generation, dual-tower flagship CPU cooler that Noctua introduced on July 2 for Intel and AMD processors, including the modern AM5 and LGA 1700 platforms, may not perform as intended, according to a new statement that the company shared today in response to user reports about how the product is louder than its predecessor, the G1. Pricing for the new cooler, including its variants and NF-A14x25r G2 PWM fans, can be found directly below.
Models/pricing:
- NH-D15 G2: EUR 149.90 / USD 149.90
- NH-D15 G2 LBC: EUR 149.90 / USD 149.90
- NH-D15 G2 HBC: EUR 149.90 / USD 149.90
- NF-A14x25r G2 PWM: EUR 39.90 / USD 39.90
- NF-A14x25r G2 PWM Sx2-PP: EUR 79.80 / USD 79.80
Noctua writes:
- “We’re still in the process of conducting a thorough analysis, but our preliminary suspicion is that you have received a heatsink where the interlocking of the top fin has loosened a bit, probably in shipping.”
- “In this case, the airflow of the fans can cause the fin to vibrate, which may result in slight rattling sounds. From our measurement, the acoustic impact of this is very small (<0.5dB(A)).”
- “…we fully understand that this is frustrating and we’re working hard to provide a solution to customers who are affected by this as soon as possible.”
- “As a temporary mitigation, we would recommend either putting a piece of tape to the side of the fins (where they interlock) or inserting a small piece of plastic or foam with ~1.8mm thickness between the top fin and second fin.”
- “Both measures should prevent the top fin from moving and thereby eliminate the sounds you hear.”
The original word from Noctua:
First of all thank you very much for choosing our NH-D15 G2. We’re sorry to hear that you have encountered an issue with your unit. We’re still in the process of conducting a thorough analysis, but our preliminary suspicion is that you have received a heatsink where the…
— Noctua (@Noctua_at) July 15, 2024
Some promos for the new cooler:
From a report:
The frequency analysis shows increased noise output at 500 and 630 Hz on the G2 compared to the G1 results, but the difference is not that high. In general, the difference in noise output is NOT high, as a raw number, but still, this noise will be highly annoying to some users because of the rattling sound.
Join the discussion in The FPS Review Forums...
Discussion (5 replies)
Join Discussion →
150 for a rattle toy? What has this world become?
But seriously, 150 for an air cooler is absolute insanity, we built whole computers for that price 15 years ago.
"MadMummy76, post: 87323, member: 1298" wrote:But seriously, 150 for an air cooler is absolute insanity, we built whole computers for that price 15 years ago.
It is expensive but with AIO's going for up to 400€ I think it's reasonable if performance and quality is there.
Granted my new AIO was just below 100€ and it performs fine so far, I did have 2 AIO's die on me in the last 10 months which was a huge pita.
"Denpepe, post: 87324, member: 284" wrote:It is expensive but with AIO's going for up to 400€ I think it's reasonable if performance and quality is there.
I've seen 360mm units hit as low as ~US$100 - you certainly can pay more, but most folks simply won't need it.
"Denpepe, post: 87324, member: 284" wrote:Granted my new AIO was just below 100€ and it performs fine so far, I did have 2 AIO's die on me in the last 10 months which was a huge pita.
You have some very surprising luck with these things, I must say :)
"LazyGamer, post: 87333, member: 1367" wrote:You have some very surprising luck with these things, I must say :)
Not realy, MSI AIO's have been know to fail en masse, the replacement one was the same model as the one that died, I hoped it was a newer revision not having the same flaw but alas.
Now let's see how Cooler Master does.
"Denpepe, post: 87324, member: 284" wrote:It is expensive but with AIO's going for up to 400€ I think it's reasonable if performance and quality is there.
Granted my new AIO was just below 100€ and it performs fine so far, I did have 2 AIO's die on me in the last 10 months which was a huge pita.
I have an AIO that costs less than $100, and works better than my NH-D15 which has been relegated to closet duty after trying it once with AM4 and getting worse results than both AIOs I had.
Discussion (5 replies)
Join Discussion →150 for a rattle toy? What has this world become?
But seriously, 150 for an air cooler is absolute insanity, we built whole computers for that price 15 years ago.
It is expensive but with AIO's going for up to 400€ I think it's reasonable if performance and quality is there.
Granted my new AIO was just below 100€ and it performs fine so far, I did have 2 AIO's die on me in the last 10 months which was a huge pita.
I've seen 360mm units hit as low as ~US$100 - you certainly can pay more, but most folks simply won't need it.
You have some very surprising luck with these things, I must say :)
Not realy, MSI AIO's have been know to fail en masse, the replacement one was the same model as the one that died, I hoped it was a newer revision not having the same flaw but alas.
Now let's see how Cooler Master does.
I have an AIO that costs less than $100, and works better than my NH-D15 which has been relegated to closet duty after trying it once with AM4 and getting worse results than both AIOs I had.